Research on the System of Compensation for Mental Damage in Breach of Contract under Chinese Law: Focusing on Article 996 of Chinese Civil Code
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.62486/agma2025215Keywords:
Breach of Contract, Compensation for Mental Damage, Personality Rights, Emotional InterestsAbstract
Although the introduction of Article 996 of Chinese Civil Code has resolved the dilemma of lacking legal basis for compensation for mental damage in breach of contract and provided significant room for the development of the system of compensation for mental damages in breach of contract, this research remains unclear in terms of legal nature of the right of claim, the scope of personality rights, and the evaluation of severe mental damage. This has led to significant differences in the legal basis and outcomes of judicial decisions in practice, affecting the consistency and authority of the law. This research focuses on Article 966 of Chinese Civil Code, employing methods such as literature analysis and case method to explore the fundamental legal nature, scope of application, and objective criteria for determination under Article 996 of Chinese Civil law. Additionally, it uses comparative method to examine the systems of compensation for mental damage in breach of contract in major civil law and common law jurisdictions. Finally, the research proposes three recommendations: clarifying the independent legal nature of claim for compensation for mental damage, enumerating specific types of contracts to expand “damage to personality rights” to “damage to special emotional interests”, and establishing an objective evaluation standard for severe mental damage by comprehensively considering medical, psychological, and legal factors.
References
Cui Jianyuan. (2012). Compensation for Damages in Tort is Not Exclusive to Tort Law, Law Science Magazine.33(08): 22–30.
. Wang v. Beijing Deng Gao er ge network technology co., ltd.[2024] Jing 0105.Min Chu. No. 3309.
. Zhou Jianghong. (2021). Research on the Legislation of Service Contracts.Beijing: Law Press. 2.
. Wu Luanfeng. (2019). On Compensation for Breach of Contract Involving Emotional Performance Interests: Theoretical Construction Based on 62 Wedding Photography Contract Judgments. Journal of East China University of Political Science and Law. 22(4). 178-192.
. Ran v. Yuan [2009] Fu Law Min Chu No. 470.
Xu Sumin. (2023). Judicial Application of the Civil Code’s Provisions on Compensation for Emotional Distress in Breach of Contract: An Empirical Study Based on 202 Cases. Finance and Law Journal, (1). 65.
. Wu Xiangxiang. (2021). Handbook on the Basis of Claims under the Civil Code.Beijing: China Legal Publishing House. 141.
. Ren Mingyan. (2021). An Analysis of the New Provisions on Compensation for Emotional Distress in Breach of Contract under the Civil Code. People’s Court Daily.(1). p. 7.
. Liu Juan v. Shenyang Bafang Passenger Transport Co., Ltd. [2022] Liao 1081 Min Chu No.540.
. Wang Kun v. Beijing Nature Wood Industry Co., Ltd. [2021] Min Jing Shen No.3156.
. Bai Zhonghui v. Yunnan International Travel Service Co., Ltd. et al. [2022] Yun 0324 Min Chu No.1097.
. Zhao Hongzhen v. Guizhou Zunyi Branch of Chongqing Qianlixing Travel Service Co., Ltd [2021] Qian Min Zhong No.10407.
. Hong Guosheng. (2025). Justification and Rule Construction for Compensation of Emotional Performance Benefits. Law Science.(01). 122.
. Meng Xiaoling. (2025). On the Application of Compensation for Spiritual Damages in Breach of Spiritual Interest Contracts. Culture Journal.(02). 150.
. Wang Limin. (2009). Personality Rights Law. Beijing: Renmin University of China Press. 334.
. Xu Sumin. (2023). Judicial Application of the Provision on Compensation for Spiritual Damages in Breach of Contract under the Civil Code: An Empirical Study Based on 202 Cases After the Enforcement of the Civil Code. Journal of Financial and Economic Law.(01). 96.
. Huang Xiuzhong v. Guide County Jin Shi You Yuan Wedding Shop [2021] Qing 2523 Min Chu No.165.
. Jiang Shangjiao v. Beijing Xixi Yuanyuan Wedding Service Center [2021] Jing 0107 Min Chu No.6415.
. Li Tiantong v. Liaoning Nanfang Creative Culture Media Co., Ltd. [2022] Liao 0402 Min Chu No.1491.
. Cai Xinyan. (2024).Research on Psychological Damages for Breach of Contract Infringing Personality Rights. Master Thesis. University of Wu Han. 29.
. Shen Xiaoming. (2004). Several Proposals for Improving Chinese Current Mental Damages Compensation System. Journal of Law Application. 69-71.
. He Tingting. (2022). On the System of Compensation for Mental Damages in Breach of Contract: Focusing on Article 996 of the Civil Code. Master Thesis. Southwest University of Political Science and Law. 39.
. Zhang Tianheng v Bei Jing Hongfeng Nursing Home for the Aged.[2021] Jing Min Shen No.4365
. W.V. Horton Rogers. (2012) Compensation for Non-pecuniary Losses from the Perspective of Comparative Law. Trans. Xu Cuixia. Beijing: China Legal Publishing House. 330.
. Wang Hongliang. (2016). General Principles of the Law of Obligations.Beijing: Peking University Press. 414.
. Han Shiyuan. (2018). General Principles of Contract Law. Beijing: Law Press China. 780. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/9781316816912.003
. Chen Weizuo. (2015).German Civil Code (4th ed.). Beijing: Law Press China. 88.
. Zhou Hongjiang. (2021). Research on the Legislation of Service Contracts.Beijing: Law Press. 84-85.
. Liu Xiaoxuan & Zheng Chengliang. (2022). The Applicability Dilemma and Resolution Path of the System for Compensation of Mental Damages in Breach of Contract under the Perspective of the Civil Code. Contemporary Law Review. 36(03). 91.
. Porchet v. Rosa Bonheur. Paris.lere. 4 juillet 1865. D. 1865.2.201.
. Wang Liming. (2021).Commentary on the Rights Volume of the Chinese Civil Code. Beijing : People’s Court Press. 113.
. Liu Yingjie. (2024). Research on Compensation for Mental Damages in Breach of Contract. Master Thesis. Jilin University. 28.
. Wang Xiuyu. (2023).Experimental Study of Mental Damages for Breach of Contract : Centered on the Application of Article 996 of the Civil Code. Master Thesis. Shandong University. 24.
. Lamm v. Shingleton 55S.E. 2d 810,812 (N.C. 1949) DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.2.4631.812
. Zhang Weiping. (2020). Coordination and docking between the implementation of civil code and civil procedure law. Chinese and Foreign Law. 32(04). 933.
. Yang Guangsu v. Sichuan Leyou Holiday International Travel Agency. [2021] Chuan 01 Min Zhong No.19721
. Vernon Valentine Palmer. (2021). Moral Damages: The French Awakening in the Nineteenth Century.Tulane University Law Review. (36).45. DOI: https://doi.org/10.37381/wkp2ga95
. Zhu Zhen. (2022). On “Severity” in Compensation for Mental Damage Caused by Infringement of Personality Rights. Law and Social Development.28(03). 140-141.
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2025 Yuanyuan Guo, Hazlina Shaik Md Noor Alam, Nur Khalidah Dahlan (Author)
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
The article is distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License. Unless otherwise stated, associated published material is distributed under the same licence.
